Queen Liluokalani

1893 Overthrow of the Government

The 1893 Overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom: A Pivotal Moment in Hawaiian History

​The overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom in 1893 stands as a watershed moment in Hawaiian history, marking the end of the sovereign monarchy and setting the stage for Hawaii's eventual annexation by the United States.​ This complex event, steeped in political intrigue and cultural tension, continues to resonate with Hawaiians and historians alike.

Background and Context

By the late 19th century, the Hawaiian Kingdom, under the rule of Queen Liliuokalani, was facing increasing pressure from American business interests and political factions. The kingdom had long been a target for economic exploitation due to its strategic location in the Pacific and its lucrative sugar industry.

Key figures in the overthrow included:

  • Queen Liliuokalani: The last monarch of Hawaii, who sought to strengthen the monarchy and protect native Hawaiian rights.
  • Sanford B. Dole: A prominent lawyer and son of American missionaries, who would become the president of the provisional government.
  • John L. Stevens: The U.S. Minister to Hawaii, who played a controversial role in supporting the coup.

The Events of January 17, 1893

On January 17, 1893, a group of American and European businessmen, supported by U.S. Marines, staged a coup against Queen Liliuokalani. The sequence of events unfolded as follows:

  1. A group calling themselves the "Committee of Safety" organized to overthrow the monarchy.
  2. U.S. troops were landed from the USS Boston, ostensibly to protect American lives and property.
  3. The conspirators occupied government buildings and proclaimed a provisional government.
  4. Queen Liliuokalani, hoping to avoid bloodshed, yielded her authority under protest, believing the United States would eventually restore her to the throne.

Immediate Aftermath

The overthrow led to the establishment of a provisional government led by Sanford B. Dole. This government quickly sought annexation by the United States, but President Grover Cleveland, upon investigation, deemed the overthrow illegal and called for the restoration of Queen Liliuokalani.

However, the provisional government refused to cede power, and in 1894, they established the Republic of Hawaii, with Dole as its president.

Long-term Consequences

The overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom had far-reaching consequences:

  • It led to the eventual illegal annexation of Hawaii by the United States in 1898.
  • It resulted in the loss of sovereignty for the Native Hawaiian people.
  • It fundamentally altered the political, economic, and social landscape of Hawaii.
  • It remains a source of controversy and a rallying point for Hawaiian sovereignty movements.

Historical Debate and Modern Perspectives

The events of 1893 continue to be debated by historians and the public. Some view it as a necessary step towards modernization and eventual statehood, while others see it as an illegal act of imperialism that violated the rights of the Hawaiian people.

In 1993, the U.S. Congress passed a joint resolution apologizing for the overthrow, acknowledging the event as illegal and expressing regret for the "deprivation of the rights of Native Hawaiians to self-determination."

Conclusion

The overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom in 1893 remains a pivotal moment in Hawaiian history. It marked the end of an era and the beginning of a new chapter in Hawaii's relationship with the United States. Understanding this event is crucial for comprehending the complex political and cultural landscape of modern Hawaii and the ongoing discussions about Hawaiian sovereignty and identity.

Today's Overview of the Overthrow

Dr. Keanu Sai - Explains the overthrow through an International Lens.

​The Hawaiian Kingdom was illegally overthrown by the United States in 1893, leading to a prolonged occupation that continues to have significant implications for Hawaii's legal status and its people.​ Despite the overthrow of its government, Hawaii's status as an independent state under international law remains intact, similar to other countries that have experienced military interventions.

1. The Overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom

On January 16, 1893, United States Marines invaded the Hawaiian Kingdom, overthrowing its government. The following day, a provisional government was established, effectively acting as a puppet regime. Queen Liliuokalani conditionally surrendered to the United States and appealed to the President for intervention.

2. Presidential Investigation and Findings

President Grover Cleveland initiated an investigation into the overthrow on March 11, 1893. After 11 months, on December 18, 1893, he reported his findings and conclusions to Congress, acknowledging the illegal nature of the overthrow.

3. Continued Existence of Hawaii as a State

Despite the military overthrow of its government, Hawaii's status as an independent state under international law remained unaffected. This principle is consistent with other historical examples, such as Germany after the fall of the Nazi regime or Kuwait during the Iraqi invasion.

4. Recognition of Hawaiian Statehood

The Hawaiian state was recognized as independent in 1843, with a constitutional monarchy known as the Hawaiian Kingdom government. Although this government was illegally overthrown, as admitted by the US president, the overthrow did not affect Hawaii's status as an independent state.

5. Ongoing Occupation and Its Effects

The United States has maintained a prolonged illegal occupation of the Hawaiian Kingdom, which has had harmful effects on the Hawaiian people. This situation has drawn attention from organizations like the National Education Association (NEA), which plans to publish an article documenting the illegal overthrow and its consequences.

6. Historical Parallels

The situation in Hawaii can be compared to other instances of military occupation, such as General MacArthur's role as military governor in post-war Japan or Eisenhower's position in Germany after the fall of the Nazi regime. In these cases, the occupying forces were not necessarily welcomed but were established in hostile situations.

Academic Accomplishments & Contributions

Contribution: Revealing True Data= T R U T H ! ! !

​Dr. Keanu Sai, a senior lecturer in political science and Hawaiian studies at the University of Hawaii, has been instrumental in educating students and teachers about the legal status of Hawaii as an occupied state.​ His research and teaching have contributed to a growing awareness of Hawaii's complex political history and its implications for the present day.

Academic Background and Contributions

Dr. Sai teaches a graduate-level course titled "Introduction to the Hawaiian Kingdom" in the College of Education's graduate program. This course is designed for teachers and provides in-depth knowledge about Hawaii's historical and legal status.

Doctoral Research Impact

Dr. Sai's doctoral dissertation significantly challenged the conventional narrative taught in Hawaiian studies. John Osorio, a prominent figure in the field, acknowledged that Sai's work "undermines everything we teach in Hawaiian studies." This groundbreaking research has since become the foundation for numerous other dissertations and master's theses worldwide.

Spreading Awareness

The impact of Dr. Sai's work extends beyond academia. Teachers who have taken his courses are now incorporating this knowledge into their own classrooms, spreading awareness about Hawaii's status as an occupied state.

Professional Organizations' Involvement

The Hawaii State Teachers Association, an affiliate of the largest union of school teachers and administrators in public schools, has taken steps to promote awareness of Hawaii's occupied status. In 2017, they sent delegates to a conference in Boston to discuss this issue, demonstrating the growing recognition of Hawaii's unique legal situation within educational circles.

Ongoing Research and Education

Dr. Sai continues to teach and supervise research on this topic, contributing to a broader understanding of Hawaii's legal status under international law. His work is part of a larger movement to reassess and accurately represent Hawaii's complex political history and current situation.

We need your consent to load the translations

We use a third-party service to translate the website content that may collect data about your activity. Please review the details in the privacy policy and accept the service to view the translations.